COVID-19 Crisis Standards of Care Resources
Topic Collection
November 23, 2022
Topic Collection: COVID-19 Crisis Standards of Care Resources
This Topic Collection focuses on plans, tools, templates, and other immediately implementable resources to help with COVID-19 preparedness, response, recovery, and mitigation efforts, focusing on crisis standards of care (CSC). Implementing CSC in a hospital setting should be a last resort when all other surge strategies have failed and no other regional resources are available. Planners need to account for three domains:
· Concept of operations – What is the process for making decisions? Who makes the decisions? How is this integrated with the incident command system?
· Criteria – What will the decisions be based upon? Using the best evidence available, primarily prioritizing interventions on the basis of prognosis and duration of use.
· Coordination – How does the facility coordinate with others in the area through healthcare coalition/ other constructs to assure consistency of care and decision making?
The following are selected best practices designed for quick reference and application.
Please refer to CDC’s Coronavirus Disease 2019 webpage for the most up-to-date clinical guidance on COVID19 outbreak management.
If you have COVID-19 best or promising practices, plans, tools, or templates to share with your peers, please visit the ASPR TRACIE Information Exchange COVID-19 Information Sharing Page (registration required) and place your resources under the relevant topic area. Resources specific to CSC can be placed under the COVID-19 Crisis Standards of Care Resources Topic.
General Resources
This document highlights guidance from the AMA Code of Medical Ethics relevant to physicians making decisions about the allocation of scarce resources during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This document provides guidance to registered nurses and institutions about the provision of patient care during extreme circumstances such as the COVID-19 pandemic.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This webinar was the fourth in a series of COVID-19 Conversations. Presenters offered an overview of crisis standards of care, discussed adapting them during the COVID-19 pandemic, and highlighted practical and ethical considerations of enacting crisis standards of care. The webinar recording, transcript, and presenter slides are available for review.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This article addresses the ethical underpinnings of considering the needs of children versus adults during the COVID-19 pandemic when resources may be scarce.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
The resources on this page can help healthcare and emergency management planners prepare for surges of COVID-19 patients.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
The speakers in this webinar discussed clinical consultation versus triage support, systems-level information sharing, coalition-level coordination activities, and recent publications/resources to help with crisis standards of care planning efforts.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This ASPR TRACIE Technical Assistance response covers Crisis Standards of Care (CSC) for infectious diseases.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This ASPR TRACIE tip sheet summarizes four healthcare executives’ experience with statewide patient surge management during COVID-19 and lessons learned gleaned from other resources. (Access the full report here: https://files.asprtracie.hhs.gov/documents/innovations-in-covid-19-patient-surge-management-final-508.pdf)
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This resource includes links to quick sheets on crisis standards of care (CSC) considerations. Topics include principles of CSC, information for planners and healthcare providers, clinical allocation decisions, public messaging, and roles and responsibilities.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This ASPR TRACIE technical assistance response describes strategies for addressing strain on U.S. hospitals (due in part to increases in seasonal respiratory viruses and issues with available space and staffing), including specific data points and operational strategies.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
The articles in this issue focus on ethical dilemmas during and beyond COVID-19, ethical issues specific to COVID-19 treatment and vaccination, crisis standards of care, and patient load balancing.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
The authors conducted a series of 15 discussions with 324 members of the public and health-related professionals to characterize the public's values regarding how scarce mechanical ventilators should be allocated during an influenza pandemic, and to inform a statewide scare resource allocation framework. They concluded that awareness of how “the values expressed by the public and front-line clinicians sometimes diverge from expert guidance in important ways,” should inform policy making.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
The 11 suggestions highlighted in this article can help those involved in large-scale pandemics or disasters with multiple critically ill or injured patients (e.g., front-line clinicians and hospital administrators) make more informed decisions about critical care triage.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This document provides select healthcare entities (e.g., nursing homes, assisted living facilities, Intermediate Care Facilities for Individuals with Intellectual Disabilities, long-term acute care hospitals, inpatient rehabilitation facilities, and dedicated hospice facilities) an overview of general considerations, potential strategies, and existing resources they may use to inform changes to their COVID-19 related operations and crisis standards of care (CSC) processes. It is intended to complement, not replace, existing state and/or local guidance and plans for implementing CSC.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This document provides an overview of general considerations, potential strategies, and existing resources that emergency medical services (EMS) agencies may use to inform changes to their operations and standards of care to preserve and effectively allocate EMS during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This panel of experts reviewed the literature and developed 23 suggestions into four categories related to clinician engagement and education: situational awareness, clinician roles and responsibilities, education, and community engagement.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This article presents ten new suggestions from the Task Force for Mass Critical Care based on the response to COVID-19 to help hospitals and communities operationalize strategies to avoid crisis standards of care. These suggestions focus on staffing, load-balancing, communications, and technology.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
The authors review health impacts of moderate to severe pandemics, health system capacity, and ethical values for rationing health resources in a pandemic. They offer six recommendations to address the question of who should get health resources during the COVID-19 pandemic: 1) maximizing benefits, 2) targeting critical interventions to those caring for ill patients and operating critical infrastructure first, 3) randomizing allocation for those with similar prognoses, 4) differing prioritization guidelines by intervention and altering those guidelines based on changing scientific evidence, 5) prioritizing interventions to reward those willing to assume personal risk by participating in safety and effectiveness research, and 6) allocating scarce resources to patients with COVID-19 and those with other conditions in the same way.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This two-pager summarizes critical care planning for COVID-19. It includes a figure depicting the expansion of critical care from conventional to contingency/crisis levels. The document offers key points to operationalize the concept in terms of space, staffing, supplies and to provide critical care.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
The authors highlight gaps in contingency and crisis standards of care planning uncovered during the COVID-19 pandemic and provide recommendations for hospitals that can help ensure an effective, fair response in the future.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This discussion paper describes the application of crisis standards of care principles to clinical care challenges posed by a coronavirus or other epidemic or pandemic. The authors encourage healthcare facilities to develop a process for decision making based on the best available clinical information and built upon existing surge capacity plans.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This discussion paper reviews some of the lessons learned related to crisis standards of care principles and practices during the COVID-19 pandemic and identifies issues and action steps for the future.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
The authors reviewed a U.S. cohort of 15,000 ventilated patients with COVID-19 hospitalized between January 1, 2020, and February 14, 2021 to validate the predictive capacity of the preintubation SOFA score. They found the tool has low accuracy for predicting mortality and recommend reviewing triage pathways.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This web page includes several resources that healthcare facilities may use to plan for medical surge caused by COVID-19.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This rapid expert consultation articulates guiding principles, key elements, and core messages undergirding crisis standards of care decision making. The document is also available to read or download at https://www.nap.edu/catalog/25765/rapid-expert-consultation-on-crisis-standards-of-care-for-the-covid-19-pandemic.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This resource builds upon prior consultation (issued on March 28, 2020) and focuses on Crisis Standards of Care and staffing needs--including deployment and allocation of expert clinical staff--to ensure the care of COVID-19 patients.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This document highlights language that supports the adherence to civil rights laws and disability rights laws in the application of Crisis Standards of Care during resource-constrained emergencies, such as the COVID-19 pandemic.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This memoranda highlights findings from a virtual meeting held in January 2021 with frontline clinicians and public health officials from across the U.S. who discussed how they were meeting challenges associated with oxygen and supply shortages.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
Based on the currently available number of ventilators in the US in acute care hospitals and the Strategic National Stockpile, the authors of this perspective article estimate that each ventilator may be needed for a range of 1.4 to 31 patients during the COVID-19 pandemic. To prepare for the potential need to ration ventilators, the authors suggest establishing a committee excluding clinicians providing patient care to set the triage criteria and adjust those criteria as the overall situation changes. Additionally, they recommend proactive engagement with high-risk patients and their families about “do not intubate” orders and establishing a voluntary team with palliative care and emotional support expertise to withdraw mechanical ventilation rather than those clinicians caring for patients.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This resource provides: background information on crisis standards of care, scarce resource cards for potentially limited resources, algorithms, worksheets, triage team guidelines, and implementation recommendations.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
Plans, Tools, and Templates
The Sequential Organ Failure Assessment (SOFA) score was designed as a research tool so that groups of patients could be categorized based on their risk of death. This fact sheet includes an overview of the score, how it is calculated, and how it can be used in triage situations.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This comprehensive crisis standards of care plan outlines state-level process and decision making and resource allocation during events that surpass available capacities and capabilities and provides a structure for clinical decisions (though some of the triage decision tools are not the most current). The plan also details a robust engagement and development process.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This toolkit contains key concepts, guidance, and practical resources to help individuals across the emergency response system develop plans for crisis standards of care and respond to a catastrophic disaster. It includes sample indicators, triggers, and sample tactics for use in the transition from conventional surge to contingency surge to crisis surge, and a return from crisis response to conventional response including templates for no-notice and prolonged incidents.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
Table 8.1 provides specific indicators, triggers, and tactics for hospitals to use along the continuum of care during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
The authors highlight gaps in contingency and crisis standards of care planning uncovered during the COVID-19 pandemic and provide recommendations for hospitals that can help ensure an effective, fair response in the future.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This document outlines a process states can use to gather hospital data needed to identify where ventilators are needed and deliver them directly to receiving hospitals.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This Word template may be used by healthcare facilities to develop a CSC plan.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This decision tree is intended for use by healthcare facilities to guide triage planning during a CSC situation.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article
This template provides background rationale and considerations for the use of crisis standards of care (CSC), examples of scoring systems, links to state CSC pediatric annexes, a pediatric CSC reference table, and legal decision factors.
Login to rate, favorite, and comment on the article